This contest covers Season 1 only. The contest is Who is the Most Dishonest? Notice the question is not who is the greatest liar - but who is the most "dishonest". Being a liar and being dishonest are two different and distinct things. Before you jump right in with an answer, consider all the possibilities.
J.R. - seems an almost too obvious choice.
John Ross - probably other people's first choice, but wait ...
Christopher - did Christopher tell Rebecca about his relationship with Elena before marrying her? How does blackmail rate on the dishonesty scales?
Rebecca - also seems like a too obvious choice. But ask yourself this question. Do you believe that Rebecca honestly loves Christopher?
Elena - was she honest with John Ross about her break-up with Christopher? John Ross said he thought she had broken up with Christopher. How honest is it to take up with the cousin of your ex and not tell him what happened between you and his cousin? A better question - who does Elena "honestly" love?
Bobby - it is far too easy to cross Bobby off this list. But consider this question. Hasn't Bobby been subtley manipulating Christopher to stay in his marriage to Rebecca?
Ann - we know she's keeping secrets from Bobby.
Sue Ellen - at the drop of a hat, Sue Ellen will bribe and blackmail anyone to save her son. Yet she campaigns as the "honest" candidate.
We'll stick to the main cast.