+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 15 of 15

Thread: Doctor Who what ifs???

  1. #1
    Oscar winner Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela is a Karma Chameleon Pamela's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 1997
    Location
    UK London
    Posts
    21,263
    My Mood
    Amazed
    Blog Entries
    1
    Karma
    390904

    Doctor Who what ifs???

    Ok.....

    In water of mars when the nuclear explosion went off, what if the Doctor was in that and completely vapourised. How would he regenerate? Where would he appear?
    Tempo al tempo

  2. #2
    Soapy Director J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    a power complex
    Posts
    5,120
    My Mood
    Relaxed
    Karma
    3750590

    He might not appear at all, if there was nothing left to regenerate...but nothing is really settled. In "The War Games" episode 10 (1969), the Doctor (Patrick Troughton in his final regular appearance as the Doctor) says that the Time Lords can live forever, barring accidents.

    In Robert Holmes' "The Deadly Assassin" (1976), the thirteen lives rule is introduced... and there are instances of permanent Time Lord death from shooting in both stories.

    What I want to know is how the Doctor managed to get his clothes to regenerate with him with the changes from selves 1-2 and 4-5!
    Last edited by J. R.'s Piece; 11-22-2009 at 01:31 PM.

  3. #3
    Soapy Director J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    a power complex
    Posts
    5,120
    My Mood
    Relaxed
    Karma
    3750590

    ...although some of the "Time Lords" shown on screen may not actually have been Time Lords....

  4. #4
    Soapy Director J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    a power complex
    Posts
    5,120
    My Mood
    Relaxed
    Karma
    3750590

    ...but lots of things that happen on Doctor Who can easily be covered in a line. For instance, Russell T Davies said that he nearly included a line along the lines of "thank goodness we were given 152 extra regenerations to fight in the Time War", thus ensuring many future Doctors.

  5. #5
    Soap Chat's Real 007 Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Sumner Ranch
    Posts
    18,686
    Karma
    69131

    What if Tom had survived the fall off that tower, and sacked the 3 assistants straight after...

    "U look so fine, I want to break your heart, and give you mine"

  6. #6
    Soapy Director J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    a power complex
    Posts
    5,120
    My Mood
    Relaxed
    Karma
    3750590

    Tom didn't fall off the tower. The Fourth Doctor fell from the tower. Tom Baker wasn't responsible for hiring or firing the performers playing the Doctor's "assistants". If Tom had fallen from the tower, he really wouldn't have been in much of a state to sack anyone because he would have required medical attention. Fortunately, as Tom was leaving the show anyway and the assistants were all set to accompany the new Doctor, hopefully Tom's injuries wouldn't have drastically affected production....and as Tom spent a lengthy period of being out of work following his stint on the show (unlike Patrick Troughton obviously, who was back at the BBC playing the Duke of Norfolk opposite Keith Michell's Henry VIII a couple of weeks after he finished on Doctor Who), he would have had plenty of time to fully recuperate at length without it harming his career.

    The Mark Gatiss-scripted episode, "The Idiot's Lantern" had included a line where the Doctor said that he didn't like towers because he fell off one once but it was removed at a late stage.
    Last edited by J. R.'s Piece; 12-13-2009 at 05:41 PM.

  7. #7
    Soap Chat's Real 007 Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Sumner Ranch
    Posts
    18,686
    Karma
    69131

    Quote Originally Posted by J. R.'s Piece View Post
    Tom didn't fall off the tower. The Fourth Doctor fell from the tower.
    Tom Baker wasn't responsible for hiring or firing the performers playing the Doctor's "assistants".. edit
    wow, Captain Obvious help you with this one JRP ?

    "U look so fine, I want to break your heart, and give you mine"

  8. #8
    Soapy Director J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    a power complex
    Posts
    5,120
    My Mood
    Relaxed
    Karma
    3750590

    No one assisted me. It isn't a matter of whether it was obvious or not but a matter of accuracy, merely correcting the flaws in your initial question and the contradiction between it and your subsequent response.

  9. #9
    Soap Chat's Real 007 Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Sumner Ranch
    Posts
    18,686
    Karma
    69131

    ... and no doubt adding how wonderful the old Trout man was,
    I see his name somewhere in the text after the point I stopped reading.

    "U look so fine, I want to break your heart, and give you mine"

  10. #10
    Soapy Director J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    a power complex
    Posts
    5,120
    My Mood
    Relaxed
    Karma
    3750590

    Excellent! More efficient use of time!

  11. #11
    Soap Chat's Real 007 Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Sumner Ranch
    Posts
    18,686
    Karma
    69131

    ... keep reaching for that rainbow, believe !!

    "U look so fine, I want to break your heart, and give you mine"

  12. #12
    Soapy Director J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    a power complex
    Posts
    5,120
    My Mood
    Relaxed
    Karma
    3750590

    I already have several pots of gold from 'em, Greggybaby!

    Talking of Rainbow, the latest DWM has a picture of Zippy (voiced by Doctor Who actor & voice artist, Roy Skelton) influenced by "Time Lord victorious", noting that it has led to the death of Bungle.

  13. #13
    Soap Chat's Real 007 Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Sumner Ranch
    Posts
    18,686
    Karma
    69131

    Bungle is dead ?? When the hell did that happen??

    Wasn't the bloody Sontarans again?? Probic vent ??

    "U look so fine, I want to break your heart, and give you mine"

  14. #14
    Soapy Director J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece is a Karma Chameleon J. R.'s Piece's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    a power complex
    Posts
    5,120
    My Mood
    Relaxed
    Karma
    3750590

    It says "Time Lord Victorious" sets bad example to other children's favourites.....see Inexplicable Death of Bungle p.74. Zippy is pictured in front of a rainbow, saying "TOUGH!"

    There is also this:
    ADVERTISEMENT
    "Unwanted gold? Broken gold? Murray Gold?.....Wait no further - send your gold to VOGA, Planet of Gold c/o Kellman, Nerva Beacon and get ££££s!"

    "I couldn't believe it! I walked away with 40 Gallifounds!" -Gold Usher, Gallifrey
    "With thirty groats for my arrows, all things shall soon be mine!" -L. Peinforte, Windsor
    "Now I'll never know if I was right!" -Adric, Freighter
    Small print warning - Gold may cause breathing difficulties. Keep gold away from Cybermats. My Skystriker can go up as well as down."
    Last edited by J. R.'s Piece; 12-13-2009 at 08:29 PM.

  15. #15
    Soap Chat's Real 007 Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory is a Karma Chameleon Mayor Gregory's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Sumner Ranch
    Posts
    18,686
    Karma
    69131

    ... no chance of a regeneration ... into say Paddington ? ... or Rupert the Bear?

    "U look so fine, I want to break your heart, and give you mine"

+ Reply to Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts